| Classification | Cru Classe |
| Type | Red |
| Producer | Il Carnasciale |
| Wine | Caberlot |
| Vintage | 2019 |
| Country | Italy |
| Region | Tuscany |
| Volume | 1,5 |
| Condition | In single OWC |
| Label | Perfect |
| Drinkable | 2023-2045 |
| Stock | 11 |
The 2019 growing season in Tuscany turned out to be the balanced year many producers had hoped for: cool nights, stable summers, and no late harvests. For Il Carnasciale, which grows Caberlot grapes on a small plot in Valdarno, these conditions led to wines with both structure and freshness. We call 2019, along with 2015 and 2016, one of the most powerful vintages in recent memory.
The Il Carnasciale 2019 Il Caberlot shows good ripeness, concentration and aromatic intensity. Although this wine is normally sold in magnum, I tasted a smaller bottle called Sommelleria. The price you see here is for the magnum. The 2019 vintage offers beautiful weight and roundness of fruit that wraps smoothly over the palate. There is sweet cherry, black fruit, spice and grilled herb. Winemaking starts off in stainless steel, with careful punch-downs lasting from 20 to 30 days, depending on the harvest conditions. It does malolactic fermentation in barrique with stirring of the lees. This vintage shows a pretty acidic signature to close.
A classy red, complex and delineated, yet elegant and supple in texture, setting the stage for black currant, blackberry, violet, cedar, rosemary and mineral flavors. Balanced and incisive on the long finish, with a lingering aftertaste that echoes the fruit, mineral and savory notes. Superb. Best from 2025 through 2042.
Fragrant nose of blueberries, violets, peppercorns, sage, five spice and lemon leaves. Medium-bodied with firm, fine tannins. Compact and firm. Lots of character, with perfumed tea-leaf notes at the end. e.
Deep, lustrous ruby. Finely perfumed nose layered with complex oak, which still needs to integrate further, and morocco leather. On the palate, intense red fruit laced with oak. Lots of juice and with finely chiselled tannins. Long, suave and elegant. One of the best Caberlots ever made.
The 2019 Il Caberlot (Sommeleria) is a powerful, intensely aromatic red from Il Carnasciale. Layers of flavor and texture build effortlessly, leading into a long, plush finish that is wonderfully inviting, even in the early going. Readers should note that the Sommeleria is not a new wine but the designation the estate has used for their 750ml bottling, mostly intended for restaurants, since 2013.
Dark, rich ruby with gently brightening rim. Beautiful spice on the nose, plus vibrant plum, strong pepper spiciness, meaty and bloody, in the background some bay leaf and rosemary, violets. Very fresh and balanced on the palate, with crisp fruit and juicy tannin, seems light on its feet and complex at the same time, draws up tight and salty, clear, spicy and very long. A long distance runner.
The first thing that catches the eye is exuberance. Cabernet Franc's split personality (Cabernet Franc aromas, Merlot flesh) is clearly evident in 2019: violets, blackcurrant leaf, then dark plum and graphite. The palate is dense but not heavy. The tannins are firm, fine-grained and covered in fruit. Thanks to the cool nights of this vintage, the acidity is still there and keeps the long, savory finish from feeling heavy.
Drinkable roughly between 2027 and 2045. The skeleton, with fine tannins, real acidity, concentrated fruit, and 24 months of French oak aging giving it power and longevity. Open it now and you can see what lies ahead. But patience will be rewarded; store at 12-14°C.
Podere Il Carnasiale is the only producer on earth that uses Caballo, a natural hybrid of Cabernet Franc and Merlot, bred by agronomist Remigio Bordini near Verona. It was only at this small estate in Valdarno, founded by Wolff and Bettina Rogoski, that Bordini allowed vines to be planted. Why is this important? Because every bottle of Cabernet Sauvignon in the world comes from these few hectares of vineyards. Today, Bettina and her son Moritz run this place. We believe this is one of the most unusual projects in Italian winemaking.
The vineyard is located about 300 meters above sea level, on shaly clay-limestone soils called galestro and alberese, which are widespread in the hills of Tuscany. Why is this important? The Galestro is well drained and deeply rooted, which naturally reduces yields and concentrates fruit flavors. Because of its high elevation, nights are cool even in the hot summer months, and this diurnal variation gives the caballo its flavor. Planting density is approximately 10,000 vines per hectare. The densely planted vines are intentionally stressed, resulting in low yields.
The decisive choice at Il Carnaciare is process, not equipment. Each parcel is fermented and aged separately and then aged in French oak barriques (small 225 liter barrels) for approximately 24 months. A blind tasting is then conducted to determine which parcels will be used for the Cabello and which for the second wine, Il Carnasiale. The Cabello is only available in hand-drawn magnums (1.5 liters) with serial numbers. Magnums age slowly and are suitable for wines intended for cellar storage.
Tannins want protein and fat, acidity wants savory. The classic Tuscan answer is best:
Served at 16-18°C. Decant one hour before service.
With track & trace code