Caymus

Caymus, the wine produced by the Wagner family. Chuck Wagner and his parents, Lorna and Charlie Sr, founded this winery in 1972 with 240 cases. The winery remains entirely family-owned and operated, and the next generation is now in charge of vineyard management and winemaking.

Two Cabernets carry the Caymus name, including Special Selection, which built the winery's reputation. Surrounding them are a variety of family brands within the Wagner lineage, and there is also a second winery located in Suisun Valley, across county lines. Napa has an even more illustrious reputation. Few places are better known than this one.

The history

Long before the Caymus label came into existence, the Wagner family had been farming in Napa. Lafayette Stice, Chuck Wagner's great-grandfather, worked as a winemaker at Brun & Chaix around 1900. Meanwhile, the Glos family moved from Germany in the 1880s, settled in Howell Mountain, cleared the land, and built cabins and roads.

Lorna Belle Glos and Charlie Wagner Sr grew up about a mile apart in Rutherford and married in 1934. The two worked side by side for over 50 years. Charlie Sr, a descendant of the Alsatian farming family, had a firm belief in the potential of his vineyard.

In 1972, the couple asked their son, Chuck, who was 19 at the time, to devote himself to the commercial winery business. He agreed. The first release was 240 cases of Cabernet Sauvignon.

Early Caymus was a deliberately diverse range: it included Zinfandel, some Pinot Noir, and late-harvest Riesling. It also included Cabernet, which became the core of the range. Starting in 1975, the family began bottling a separate cuvée called Special Selection, which was produced alongside the Randy Dunn at the time and aged in oak barrels for a very long period, up to four years in some vintages, to ensure it would be approachable upon release. By the mid-1980s, this wine had become one of the most highly regarded Cabernets wines, alongside Napa's. Dunn left in 1986 and eventually established his own winery, and Chuck gradually took on more responsibility for running the business.

Charlie Sr passed away in 2002, in his 90th year.

This growth led to friction. In 2013, Caymus agreed to pay Napa County $1 million to settle allegations that it had bottled a quantity of wine far exceeding the permitted limit at the Rutherford property and had expanded the building without proper approval. Wagner stated at the time that the dispute stemmed from a difference in interpretation regarding whether bottling operations are considered part of production, and rather than engaging in a legal battle, the family reached an agreement to relocate the bottling facility to another location.

Fifty years after the release of the first vintage, the Wagners opened Caymus-Suisun, their second winery, in Suisun Valley. Today Chuck currently works alongside his children, Charlie and Jenny.

Rutherford, and a long way beyond it

Rutherford is the company's headquarters, and the tasting room there is familiar to most visitors. However, Caymus's grapes no longer come exclusively from Napa.

Starting with the 2021 vintage, the family introduced California Cabernet Sauvignon, made from grapes harvested from vineyards scattered throughout the state. This blend includes not only Paso Robles but also lesser-known vineyards such as Lake, San Benito, and Monterey Counties. The goal is to find the right climate, soil, and topography for Cabernet, and it doesn't matter where that is, as long as those conditions align.

Suisun Valley is another expanded region. It is located right next to Napa, separated only by a single county line. It was designated as AVA in 1982, one year after Napa was designated as a wine region. This land is protected as an agricultural conservation area, and most of the farms here are small, family-run operations. The Wagners were so fond of the local fruit that they began growing grapes and built a winery complete with a garden, vineyard walking trails, and an attached kitchen.

The terroir

Chuck Wagner's interpretation of California can be explained simply in one sentence. The cold Pacific Ocean runs the entire length of the state, bringing maritime influence, and the climate becomes warmer with every mile traveled inland. If you find a spot that's warm enough but not too hot, Cabernet will thrive.

The conditions he looks for in the field are consistent: stony soil, a south-facing slope, and a moderately warm environment rather than sweltering heat.

According to him, these three factors produce a dense and lush Cabernet, which explains why Caymus is willing to look as far as counties well beyond Napa. Rutherford meets these conditions. Therefore, this family argues that even the small areas of California, which almost no one has yet marked on a map for Cabernet, also meet these conditions.

The grape varieties, Cabernet first

Cabernet Sauvignon is the grape variety that forms the foundation of this winery, and under the name Caymus, it is virtually the only significant variety.

This was not always the case. In the early days, Charlie Sr bottled Zinfandel, Pinot Noir and late-harvest Riesling alongside Cabernet, and it took quite some time for the product lineup to be finalized. The focus on Cabernet began alongside Special Selection and has never wavered since.

Elsewhere within the Wagner business, other grape varieties are still waiting their turn. The Suisun Valley winery offers Emmolo sparkling wine and chilled rosé, and the family operates a separate brand at their winery in Santa Lucia Highlands. Caymus itself maintains a consistent direction.

The winemaking

Most American wine enthusiasts prefer red wines that are rich in flavor, full-bodied, and ready to drink. For the past 50 years, Caymus has aimed to achieve exactly that, and its winemaking process is designed accordingly.

Extended aging in oak barrels has been part of Special Selection's winemaking philosophy since its inception; originally, this was intended to ensure the wine was sufficiently smooth and enjoyable not just after years in the cellar, but right from the moment of release. Aromas of ripe fruit, a rich texture, and tannins that aren't overly astringent: these are the hallmarks of Caymus.

A six-person winemaking team is responsible for the family's wines, including the Suisun Valley label. The winery explains that California Cabernet is a wine that can be enjoyed both immediately upon release and after aging, which sums up their overall approach. No one at Caymus has ever told you that you need patience.

The two Cabernets

The core line of Caymus consists of three red wines:

  • Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley — the standard wine
  • Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon California 
  • Caymus Special Selection — the flagship wine, produced since 1975 and only in exceptional vintages. 

Frequently asked questions

Who owns Caymus?

The Wagner family, entirely. Chuck Wagner founded the winery with his parents in 1972 and now runs it with his children Charlie and Jenny.

What is Special Selection?

A separate Cabernet Sauvignon bottling that Caymus has made since 1975, given long barrel ageing so that it is approachable when released.

Where can you visit Caymus?

At the winery in Rutherford, Napa Valley, where seated tastings run by appointment, and at Caymus-Suisun in Suisun Valley, which also has gardens and a restaurant, Westwind Kitchen.

Is all Caymus Cabernet from Napa Valley?

No. From the 2021 vintage the family added a California Cabernet Sauvignon sourced from sites including Paso Robles and parts of Lake, San Benito and Monterey Counties.

Added to favorites.